You've taken an AncestryDNA test and now have thousands of matches, most with no tree, half with usernames like "jsmith1953," and none labeled "your Irish side." How do you turn that list into ancestors? Three techniques do most of the heavy lifting: clustering your matches with the Leeds Method, testing theories with a "test tree" and ThruLines, and uploading your raw DNA to GEDmatch for the segment-level tools Ancestry doesn't offer.
This guide explains each one, how they fit together, and the privacy points to think through before you start.
1. Sort your matches with the Leeds Method
The Leeds Method, developed by genealogist Dana Leeds, is a simple, visual way to sort your DNA matches into groups that each point to one branch of your family. All you need is your match list and a spreadsheet (or Ancestry's colored-dot groups).
How it works:
- List your 2nd and 3rd cousin matches, meaning those sharing roughly 90 to 400 cM with you. Leave out closer relatives like siblings and first cousins for now. They share more than one of your ancestral lines and would muddy the groups.
- Give the first match a color. Then open their Shared Matches and give the same color to everyone on your list who appears there.
- Move to the next uncolored match and repeat with a new color.
- Keep going until everyone in the 90–400 cM range has at least one color.
If all goes well, you'll end up with around four main color groups, one for each of your grandparents. Matches you can already identify (a known second cousin on your mother's father's side, say) tell you which group belongs to which grandparent. That leaves you free to concentrate on the group that leads to your Irish line.
Results vary. Families with intermarriage, endogamy or few testers on one side won't always sort neatly. As Leeds herself stresses, a cluster is a clue, not proof of a specific relationship.
2. Test your theories with a test tree and ThruLines
Ancestry's ThruLines feature suggests how you may be related to your matches by comparing your family tree with your matches' trees. To get ThruLines, your DNA has to be linked to a tree that is public or "private but searchable," and you need an active Ancestry membership. That opens up a powerful technique: building a test tree (sometimes called a hypothesis tree) to check a theory before you commit it to your main research.
How it works:
- Form a hypothesis. For example: "My great-great-grandfather Patrick Kelly was a son of Michael Kelly and Bridget Walsh of Kilmore parish."
- Create a separate tree containing your known ancestors plus the hypothesized ancestors, and some of their descendants if you can identify them from records. Give it a clear name like "TEST – Kelly hypothesis (unproven)."
- Link your DNA test to the test tree and set the tree to private but searchable so ThruLines can use it.
- Wait, then look. ThruLines can take a while (often a day or two) to update. If the hypothesis is right, you'd expect DNA matches to start appearing as descendants of the proposed ancestors, especially matches from the cluster you identified with the Leeds Method.
- Evaluate carefully, then relink your DNA to your main tree when you're done.
The big caveat: ThruLines builds its suggestions from other people's trees, and those trees can be wrong. A dozen matches "descending" from the same couple might all have copied the same mistake. Treat ThruLines as a pointer to check, and confirm each line of descent with records (civil, church, census) and with shared DNA amounts that make sense for the proposed relationship.
3. Why uploading to GEDmatch is worth it
AncestryDNA has the largest database of testers, which makes it the best place to find matches. But it has never given customers segment data or a chromosome browser. You can see how many centimorgans (cM) you share with a match, but not where on your chromosomes you share them. For serious research, that's a real limitation.
The good news is that Ancestry lets you download your raw DNA file, and you can upload it to GEDmatch, an independent site that accepts files from most major testing companies. GEDmatch can show you:
- One-to-one comparisons: exactly which segments, on which chromosomes, you share with a particular match. This works with matches who tested at any company and uploaded, not just Ancestry.
- Segment searching and triangulation: whether three or more people share the same segment. That's strong evidence they inherited it from the same ancestor. Some of these advanced tools need GEDmatch's paid tier.
- Matches from other companies: people who tested at 23andMe, MyHeritage or FamilyTreeDNA and uploaded to GEDmatch, and would never appear on your Ancestry list.
- "Are your parents related?": a check for runs of identical DNA that can reveal whether your parents were related, which matters in close-knit rural Irish communities.
With segment data in hand, you can use a free tool like DNA Painter to map which segments came from which ancestors. Over time this builds a picture of your chromosomes, colored by ancestor, so a new match on a mapped segment immediately tells you which branch they belong to.
MyHeritage and FamilyTreeDNA also accept uploads of Ancestry raw data and offer chromosome browsers of their own, so uploading to them too widens your net further.
4. Putting it all together
Here's how the three techniques work as one process:
- Cluster your Ancestry matches with the Leeds Method to isolate the branch you're researching.
- Mine the cluster's trees for common surnames, places and the most likely common ancestors.
- Build a test tree around your best hypothesis and see whether ThruLines and your cluster members line up with it.
- Confirm with segments: on GEDmatch (or another site with a chromosome browser), check whether matches from that branch triangulate on shared segments.
- Confirm with records: DNA points the way, but civil records, parish registers and census returns turn a theory into a proven family tree.
For Irish families, where many paper records stop before 1820, this combination is often what finally connects an American, British or Australian family to a specific Irish parish.
5. Privacy and etiquette: read this first
DNA is personal information, and it's not only yours: it also reveals things about your relatives. Before you upload anywhere, think through the following.
- Only upload DNA you have the right to share. That means your own, or that of someone who has given you clear permission (ideally in writing). Never upload a relative's DNA without their consent.
- Read each site's current terms and privacy policy. Policies change. GEDmatch is operated by Verogen, a subsidiary of Qiagen, and its terms of service include an arbitration agreement. Check the latest version before you upload.
- Understand the law-enforcement setting. GEDmatch lets each user choose whether their kit can be compared with DNA submitted by law enforcement for certain violent-crime and identification cases. Since 2019 this has required you to actively opt in. Ancestry's terms, by contrast, prohibit use of its platform for law-enforcement investigations. Either choice is a personal decision, so make it knowingly.
- Choose your visibility. GEDmatch offers different privacy levels for each kit, including a private or research setting that lets you use the tools without appearing in other people's match lists.
- Remember there's always some risk. Any online service can suffer a security problem, and GEDmatch has had problems with its settings in the past. Use a strong, unique password and only share what you're comfortable with.
- Respect your matches. Don't publish matches' names, trees or DNA details without their permission, and handle unexpected discoveries, like misattributed parentage or unknown siblings, with discretion and kindness.
- Stick to each platform's rules. Use the tools the way the sites intend. Ancestry's terms, for example, don't allow automated scraping of its site, so avoid browser add-ons or scripts that pull data from it in bulk.
Want a second pair of eyes on your matches?
DNA clustering and segment analysis can be time-consuming, especially when the paper trail is thin. If you've tested and aren't sure what your matches are telling you, get in touch for a free consultation. I'll look at what you have and suggest the most promising next steps.
AncestryDNA, Ancestry, ThruLines, GEDmatch, 23andMe, MyHeritage, FamilyTreeDNA and DNA Painter are trademarks of their respective owners. Daly Irish Roots is an independent research service and is not affiliated with, sponsored by or endorsed by any of these companies. Features, pricing and policies described here may change, so always check each company's current terms. This article is general information, not legal advice.